APEX
GOOD PROCESS VS. GOOD OUTCOME

Good process, bad outcome: why your last loss may not be a mistake

Judging a decision by its result is the most common error in investing. How to separate process from outcome, and why APEX scores them apart.

2 min read

You bought with a thesis, a stop and a reason. The price went the other way and hit the stop. Was it a mistake?

Most people answer with the result: it lost, so it was wrong. Poker players have a name for that reflex. Annie Duke calls it resulting: judging the quality of a decision by the quality of its outcome. In any activity with uncertainty, the two are only loosely connected. A good decision can lose; a bad one can win. If you grade yourself on results, you will keep the bad habits that happened to pay off and drop the good ones that happened not to.

Four boxes instead of one line

Put every closed position in one of four boxes:

  1. Good process, good outcome. You followed your plan and it worked. Fine, but learn little from it.
  2. Good process, bad outcome. You followed your plan and the market disagreed. This is the normal cost of being right only part of the time. Nothing to fix.
  3. Bad process, good outcome. You broke your rules and got paid. This is the dangerous box: it feels like skill.
  4. Bad process, bad outcome. You broke your rules and lost. Painful, but at least the lesson is visible.

The only boxes that teach anything are 3 and 4, and box 3 is the one nobody writes down.

What "process" means in practice

Process is everything you controlled before the outcome existed: whether you had a thesis, whether you defined what would prove it wrong, whether the size matched the risk you had decided to accept, whether you entered inside the zone you had planned or chased the price, whether you moved the stop once inside. None of those depends on where the price went afterwards. All of them can be checked from a record.

Why this is built into APEX

APEX's decision review diagnoses the process of a closed position without looking at the result first: did you enter before confirmation, did you ignore a counterargument you had already written, did you move the stop, did you size above your usual risk. Only then does it look at whether the trade won or lost, and a loss with a clean process is attributed to the market, in those words. A win with a broken process is labelled as what it is. The point is not to be harsh; it is to make box 3 visible before it becomes a habit.

A practical rule

Before you close the position, write one line: which box do you expect this to land in if the price went against you tomorrow? If you cannot answer, the problem is not the outcome.

None of this makes losing pleasant. It makes it informative.

Sources

  1. Annie Duke, Thinking in Bets (Portfolio/Penguin, 2018), on 'resulting'
  2. Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman, 'Judgment under Uncertainty: Heuristics and Biases', Science 185 (1974)

Keep reading

← All articles

APEX does not execute trades or guarantee results. Investing involves risk of loss.